Summary of the characteristics of the included studies.
Author, year, country | Sample number | Patient age and characteristics | Study design | Inclusion criteria | Index test (multiplex PCR) | Routine testing methods | Adjudication methods for discordant results |
Deng J et al19 2015, China | 290 stool samples | Mixed (median age of 25 months and ranging from 11 days to 83 years.) | Prospective | Diarrheal patients | Luminex xTAG | Bacterial culture, serotyping for Salmonella and Shigella, real-time reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assays for viral detection, microscopic examination for parasite detection. | Singleplex PCR andsequencing |
Chhabra P et al2 2017, USA | 300 stool samples | Mixed (from children and adults) | Retrospective | Patient with acute gastroenteritis | Luminex xTAG and FilmArray | TAC system, real-time PCR and sequencing | No |
Alejo-Cancho I et al4 2017, Spain | 95 stool samples | 95 immunocompromised adult patients, with a median age of 52 years (46–64). | Prospective | Acute diarrheal patient | FilmArray | Routine microbiological techniques, including bacterial culture, C. difficile toxin study, microsoopy for parasite, virus antigen. | Second multiplex assay (Allplex, Seegene, Korea) |
Duong VT et al5 2016, Vietnam | 479 stool samples were collected from 92 adults and 387 children | The median age of the adult patients was 50 years (interquartile range [IQR], 33 to 64 years). In children, the median age was 16.5 months (IQR, 6.7 to 20 months). | Retrospective | Diarrheal patients | Luminex xTAG | Microbiological culture and real-time PCR | No |
Khare R et al10 2014, USA | 230 prospectively collected samples and 270 additional previously characterized samples | Unclear | Prospective and retrospective | Stool samples submitted to laboratory for routine GI testing. | Luminex xTAG and FilmArray | Routine testing (e.g., culture, microscopy, antigen testing, and/or individual real-time PCR) | Real-time PCR |
Buss SN et al18 2015, USA | 1556 stool samples | Mixed (adult and children) | Prospective | Stool samples submitted with orders by the provider for stool culture | FilmArray | Stool culture, PCR | PCR and sequencing assays |
Claas EC et al9 2013, The Netherlands | 901 stool specimens | Mixed (adult and children) | Prospective | Stool collected in four hospitals | Luminex xTAG | Routine testing (e.g., culture, microscopy, EIA/DFA, or real-time PCR) | No |
Halligan E et al20 2014, UK | 2187 diarrhoeal stool samples. | Unclear | Prospective | Diarrheal patients | Luminex xTAG | Conventional tests including microbiological culture, microscopy, microwell enzyme immunoassay, immunochromatographic test | No |
Mengelle C et al21 2013, France | 440 stool samples | 4 groups included: 102 adult organ transplant recipients (mean age, 50.6; median, 56; range, 17–75), 50 immunosuppressed children (mean age, 5; median, 7; range, 0–14), 56 children attending the neonatal unit (aged under 1 year) and 121 children attending the emergency unit (mean age, 2.80; median, 9; range, 0–16). | Prospective | Diarrheal patients | Luminex xTAG | Routine diagnostic methods (e.g., culture, microscopy, immunochromatographic assay, and multiplex PCR) | No |
Zboromyrska Y et al22 2014, Spain | 185 stool samples | Traveller's diarrheal patients with unclear age | Prospective | Patients with traveller’s diarrhea | Luminex xTAG | Routine diagnostic methods (e.g., culture, microscopy, mass spectrometry, and multiplex PCR) | Conventional PCR and bidirectional sequencing |
Huang RS et al17 2016, USA | 98 retrospective and 54 prospective stool samples | Pediatric patients | Retrospective and prospective | Patient with acute gastroenteritis | Luminex xTAG and FilmArray | Conventional testing including stool cultures, immunochromatographic rapid tests, and singleplex RT-PCR | No |